THE WAY IT COULD BE:
A Visit to a Sustainable Society.
23.2.07
Ted Trainer.
Preamble.
It is increasingly obvious
that there are fatal flaws in industrial-affluent-consumer society. Most of our problems are getting
worse. In all rich countries there
is increasing inequality, social breakdown, resource depletion, debt,
deterioration of public services and a falling quality of life. We are probably within a few years of a
very serious petroleum shortage.
Even more importantly, our society is grossly ecologically
unsustainable. We are rapidly
using up the available resources and damaging the ecosystems of the
planet. There is no chance that
all the worldÕs people could have the per capita resource use rates we have in
rich countries. Yet we are obsessed with economic growth and raising Òliving
standardsÓ; i.e., with increasing our levels of production and consumption and
GNP, constantly and without any limit.
In addition we few who live in rich countries can only have
our affluent living standards because of
the gross injustice built into the global economy. We are grabbing far more than our fair
share of the world's resources and condemning most of the people in the Third
World to extreme deprivation.
There is a way out of this
alarming and accelerating predicament
--- but only if we accept
that the problems are generated by some of the fundamental principles of
consumer-capitalist society, and therefore that the problems canÕt be solved
without radical and extreme change.
We must move to The Simpler Way.
This must involve materially simpler lifestyles, high levels of local
economic self-sufficiency, more cooperative and participatory ways, a very
different economic systemÉand some
very different values.
Perhaps the most tragic
aspect of out situation is that it would be so easy to eliminate the
problems --- if we were prepared to make these
changes.
At first
encounter the idea of having to move from our present affluent living standards
can seem quite threatening, but this is a misunderstanding. The purpose of this book is to make clear how workable and
attractive the alternative could be.
We could all live very well on a small fraction of the present amount of
work and production and resource use and waste, in pleasant surroundings and in
supportive communities, with much time for arts and crafts, or learning or
personal development, and knowing that we are no longer causing global problems
--- but only if we abandon affluence and growth, and the institutions, systems
and values that go with them.
I have given an account of
the necessary alternative ways in my The Conserver Society, and more
recently a considerably revised account at http://.socialwork.arts.unsw.edu.au/tsw/12b-The-Alt-Sust-Soc-Lng.html
What I have tried to do in The
Way It Could Be is to give a much lighter and more readable account, in the
fictional form of a visit to a town that functions on alternative lines. My conviction regarding the
availability, workability and
The Simpler Way comes primarily from the fact that it is the way I have
lived my life, in so far as that it possible when one is trapped in
consumer-capitalist society. Many
of the ways dealt with in this account derive from my own experience of seeking
to live frugally and self-sufficiently on a homestead.
There is now a Global
Alternative Society Movement in which many small groups are attempting to live
in and demonstrate this way. There are now many Òeco-villagesÓ in existence
around the world. Some are
more than 20 years old. However
most are rural communities and the most important step to a sustainable world
order will be the development of alternative communities and economies within
urban situations.
Our greatest problem is the
steadfast refusal of the mainstream to address these issues, to even recognise
the possibility that consumer-capitalist society is grossly unsustainable and
unjust, and that the alarming problems facing us cannot be solved without
radical change from the obsession with affluence and growth. What then is the best strategy for us
to pursue if we wish to contribute to the transition? I firmly believe that the fate of the planet depends on
whether the Global Alternative Society Movement can establish a sufficient
number of impressive examples of The Simpler Way in the next two or more
decades, so that as mainstream consumer society runs into more serious
difficulties people will be able to see that there is a better way. The purpose of this book is to increase
the understanding that The Simpler Way would be easily established – if
we wanted to do it, that it would more or less eliminate global problems, and
that it would bring a much higher quality of life than we have now.
--------
The index lists the location
of the topics dealt with throughout the three day account.
The Way It Could Be.
Part 1 of 12.
As a journalist, Mike had come across accounts of
alternative settlements and lifestyles
from time to time and
although in general he thought well of people who lived that way he
regarded them more or less as fringe dwellers who had
opted out of conventional life. He
had never really thought of them as being of much
social significance, as in any way pioneering important new ideas and
practices. He was
therefore somewhat surprised to receive a letter
making the rather bold claim that a tiny town within a
few hours of his city held the key to a sustainable
future for the entire planet.
This sounded rather implausible but he could see the
possibility of an interesting story.
Occasional discussions with others in his pool eventually led him
to suggest the idea to
his editor, but
the project was not regarded as being
worth the time and effort.
He did
say though that if
Mike wanted to visit the place taking a few of his holidays and a
useful article came of it, then he would be willing to credit that
as work time. This put
Mike off for a while but then office
politics intervened.
The Features Department ran at a hectic pace with pressure to churn
articles out in competition with tough colleagues, always eager to get the jump
on each other in the pursuit of good stories. Then there was the competition for the investigative assignments, the
effort to fool the executives higher up to secure privileges, and jockeying for
positions likely to become vacant.
Mike had been outmanoeuvred for the office heÕd had his eyes on getting when Henry left. He was nursing the bruise that gave to
his self concept. The office and
HenryÕs job went to Madeleine, Medusa as Mike called her. He rated himself as pretty good at
street fighting – you have to be to survive at his level, but Medusa was
in mega-vicious class.
Mike recognised that he had
been outsmarted on a number of occasions in the jungle of petty office warfare
and felt that he probably deserved his place in the lower ranks of the pecking
order. If heÕd been better at the
in-fighting he'd have more than HenryÕs office by now. He could admit to himself that bad
feelings were smouldering away; how nice it would be to even some of those
scores. He always kept his eye
open for chances. But when thereÕs
a mortgage like his to live with you think twice before lashing out, and indeed
you bless your stars for having a job with a reasonable income. He knew he was lucky to have some
freedom and scope for initiative, like deciding how to approach a story, at
least before the sub-editors hacked it into what they regarded as acceptable
form. It was a long time since heÕd had
a break. So the idea of getting out for a few days became more attractive. It wasnÕt difficult to convinced
Eleanor that the trip was an assignment.
As he set out very early
that morning Mike realised that he had been so busy on other tasks that he had
done almost no homework on this project and had little idea of what he was
going to find. HeÕd left a pile of
unopened mail and folders in his tray.
He hadnÕt thought of a possible angle, let alone searching
questions. WhatÕs more, he was
most at home writing about economic affairs and was not at all familiar with
anything to do with alternative lifestyles. He decided that he might as well
take the relaxed approach – look around at a leisurely pace and chat to a
few of the locals, and just treat it mainly as a three day break from the
office. He took along a folder of
work heÕd have to get through if urgent deadlines were going to be met in the
week after, neatly tied with a red cord.
The Glen was a tiny town on
one of the minor country rail links still functioning. He had arranged to be met at the
station. When he found that that
only one train stopped there each day his doubts about the entire project rose
another notch.
He nearly missed the
stop. He was dreaming but with part
of his mind on the need to watch for the station signs. The train slowed and he was dimly
conscious of dense forest and scrub all around. The train clunked to a stop, apparently in the middle of
nowhere. He chanced to look across
the aisle and out of the window on the other side, and realised they were
standing at a primitive wooden station, and there on a seat was written ÒThe
GlenÓ. After a grab for his bags
and a scramble down the aisle he dropped awkwardly to the decking, some way
below the level of the train door.
He looked around but was the only person on the short platform. A couple of sheds, a small crane at the
end of the platform and a patch of bitumen were just about the only signs of
human settlement in the middle of what now clearly was dense forest in all
directions.
Then he saw two people
walking quickly out of the forest and towards the platform. They waved and in a few seconds Mike
had descended the ramp to meet them.
ÒHi, Mike I guess, IÕm Jan
and this is Pete.Ó
ÒGerday. Yeah, IÕm Mike.Ó
ÒSorry we werenÕt here. The train was a bit early.Ó
ÒHow was the trip?Ó
ÒNot bad. Nice to travel by train for a
change. I mostly have to drive.Ó
Jan was maybe in her
forties, somewhat tall and thin, and seemed to have an energetic manner, moving
quickly and using her hands expressively.
Pete was a little older, more stocky, and seemed to have a more slow and
relaxed manner.
After a few more words Pete
picked up one of MikeÕs bags and said, ÒWell, lets take you down town.Ó He led
off across the patch of bitumen towards the wall of forest. Mike looked around for a car, but
couldnÕt see one. Within seconds
Pete had plunged into the bush, striding along a narrow path. Mike thought, ÒDown town?Ó It suddenly struck him how thoroughly
unprepared he was, and the fumbled for a way of partly apologising for having
no idea of what he was getting involved in, and partly trying to elicit some
clues without appearing to be too incompetent.
ÒI have to confess that I
really have little idea what to expect.Ó
ÒGood.Ó said Pete. ÒBest if
it can be a discovery adventure for you.Ó
After no more than three
minutes they were coming out of the forest, as if through a curtain, and there
about three hundred metres ahead, down the slope, was the edge of a settlement
of some kind. All he could see
were some house roofs above and between the tree tops. Pete walked a few metres more and
stopped.
ÒWelcome to The Glen,Ó he said, spreading his arms as if
performing to a fanfare. ÒOur
place is only another three hundred metres or so over there, but this is a good
spot to explain a bit about the geography. WeÕve just come through what we call The Wall. Most of that forest was planted twenty
years ago, to screen us off from the railway. Twenty years ago you could see the whole town from
here. Mind you twenty years ago
there were a lot more trains thundering through all day than there are now.Ó
ÒTwenty years ago you could
see the town dying you mean,Ó Jan said.
ÒIt was a typical tiny and struggling country town. From here you could see all the streets
and just about all the houses, because the streets were pretty bare. Can you make out how those house roofs there form a
line, well they were along a street.
Our house is on that line, but you wonÕt see a street there now, just a
path with a lot of green. We dug
up the road and planted most of itÉ
Ò...and put in fish ponds
and woodlots and swings and the odd windmill. Lets go on,Ó Pete said, picking up the bag again. After a few more minutes on the path
they turned sharply through a gate in a hedge and seemed to be walking through
someoneÕs garden, then through another gate into a thicket, around a bend the
other way and out of the low hanging overhead foliage onto a small pasture
surrounded by trees, again with a few house roofs visible. They could now hear sounds of
settlement; chickens somewhere close, people talking from time to time, someone
hammering. An engine started up some way off, and then a cow could be
heard. Mike thought of traffic and
realised he couldnÕt hear any, although they were now only a few metres from
the closest houses.
Soon another gate, this one
with a low dense vine above, making Mike bend to pass thorough. As he straightened up he found himself
in a neat and compact domestic garden, with a house veranda up a few steps some
metres to the left.
ÒHere we are,Ó said
Jan. ÒThis is base camp. This is our patch. This is where youÕll
be staying.Ó Mike was caught off balance;
heÕd thought a room had been booked for him at a hotel. Well, boarding would be alright, as
long as he was left to his own devices most of the time.
They mounted the steps.
ÒTake a seat and IÕll put the kettle on.Ó
Jan directed Mike to a rocking chair. Mike put his bag down, turned and lowered himself into the
chair, gave it a little rock to get the feel, then looked up. He was surprised to find sloping away
before him an extensive landscape, with long views across clumps of trees,
fields, houses, stretches of water, to thickly forested hills not far away. Immediately in front of him was a
cottage garden beside the patch of lawn they had come across. He hadn't seen the pond, or beyond that
a low ornamental fence bordering a vegetable garden, then a chicken pen, then
orange trees and a high bamboo clump arching from the left . A little further off to the right a
thick cluster of very tall eucalypts jutted into the sky. In the middle distance were fields, a
large lake and two windmills.
Dotted throughout were several house roofs almost obscured by the dense
clumps of foliage. Mike felt he
could spend hours zooming into
parts of the complex panorama to examine what was in each little section.
"Look at this,"
Pete broke in, as came from the house holding a photograph. He gave Mike a few
seconds to get confused, then said, "This is what it looked like twenty
years ago, from right here. See
the edge of the old fence over there, that was this bit of fence in the edge of
the picture."
"But, there's a town
there," said Mike, looking up from the picture.
"Still there,"
Said Pete, ÒJust buried in the trees now.
See that's the tip of Madison's house roof, over there, see just to the
right of the oranges. And see how
those houses are in a line, along the street, well, when we go for a walk there
soon you will see they are still in that line, but not on a street; we got rid
of that."
"Got rid of it; what do
you mean?"
ÒJust dug it up and planted
it, left a wide cycle path
wandering along but mostly that area is a sort of cross between a park, a
forest and a farm now. Still all public property though."
ÒWell, well," muttered
Mike, jiggling the rocking chair around so he could face straight down the
view, and looking up at it and down to the photo again and again. "You'd never know. And the town in
the photo looks so bare, you can see road surface over there, but itÕs like a
jungle there now."
"Yep. We sure jungled Elm St. Fancy calling that strip of grey dirt
Elm St in the first place.
No elms there then, but see that crown there, that's a Pecan, and I planted
him, about eighteen years ago now.
He's one of my children you know.
There are probably another fifty of mine out there we could see from our
roof."
ÒIt sure is a nice
landscape," Mike said.
"Yes, but that's only
half the story. It is also a very
productive landscape --- we say 'edible landscape'. Nearly all the green you can see
belongs to a tree or a shrub producing something useful, mostly fruit, nuts or
timber. And just about all of it
is public, I mean itÕs planted on what were roads or parks and those areas are
now growing things for the community to use or enjoy.Ó
"..and fish," said
Jan who appeared with a tray carrying a pot, teacups and biscuits.
"Fish?"
"Yes, there are lots of
fish out there too."
"In the ponds,"
said Pete, "Énibbling the feet of all the ducks and geese out there. You can see the edge of the big pond
down there, but youÕll find many more smaller ones in among the trees.
Parallel to Elm St, about where the back fences were thereÕs a shallow
natural water drainage line. It
used to rot the wooden fence posts out.
Now itÕs been turned into a chain of ponds along a creek. Most of them have fish in them. Some have islands for particular types
of bamboo. Some bamboos will run everywhere and become a pest, so we confine
them on little islands. But
others, the clumpers, don't need that.
See that big one arching from the left just down there. He's a clumper. We get building materials from that
one, and things like our tomato stakes from the smaller ones.
"That's where our
dinner comes from," said Jan, waving at the view. ÒJust about everything we eat comes
from that scene in front of you.
We have to import a few things, but I'd say 95% of what we eat comes
from land you can see from our roof top.
Mostly vegetables and fruit, but there is also poultry, fish and rabbits
for the meat eaters. CanÕt see the dairy from here but it Ôs about a kilometre
away.Ó
ÒAnd thereÕs a lot of
manufacturing industry out there too.
YouÕll see when we go for a walk.
Many little firms and industries throbbing away. Many people work from home here, or in
small firms that are around the corner from where they live.Ò
ÓAh, that will be
interesting,Ó said Mike. ÒIÕm
interested in your economy.
I do features, investigative stuff, but mostly on economic themes.Ó
They heard the door at the front of the house open. ÒThatÕll be Gran,Ó
said Jan. And within a few seconds
an elderly lady came into the kitchen adjacent to the veranda, wearing an apron
and loaded down with baskets and bags. She was almost tiny, a little stooped and wearing
thick glasses, but moved quickly.
ÒGran, hereÕs Mike.Ó
ÒHello Michael. Nice to meet you. Are they looking
after you?Ó
Pete Said, ÒGran is the worldÕs best dinner bakerÉÓ
ÒÉand knitter and herb gardener,Ó Jan cut in. ÒThis jumper is one of her
art works.Ó Then, looking at the bags, ÒGran what on
earth have you got there?Ó .
ÒItÕs all from Mary, you know the story. I only pop in to say hello and
now itÕll take me an hour just to plant the cuttings, let alone put away all
this other treasure. Look at this
a bottle of marmalade. She says itÕs a new recipe.Ó
ÒBy the way,Ó said Jan, ÒWhereÕs Amy?Ó
ÒNo idea. Said sheÕd be
home for tea. I think she and the
Smith twins were going up to the lookout on their bikes.Ó
ÒDid she take a jumper?
ItÕll be cool this evening.Ó
ÒDonÕt know, she can always
borrow something from somewhere.Ó
Pete turned to Mike. ÒAmy
is our nine year old.
Occasionally she comes back to visit us. Spends most of her time in somebody elseÕs house.Ó
Jan said, ÒThat evens out when she brings her friends back to camp here
without any warning. ThatÕs when you send out the distress call to May for
emergency egg delivery, or to Tommy for loaves of bread. She knows Mike will be here, so sheÕll
be back sometime. You know what
she said? ÔIÕm very interested in
aliensÕ. I hope thatÕs not too offensive
Mike.Ó
ÒActuallyÓ, said Pete, ÒI should explain. In this town we feel such a huge gulf between mainstream
people and us. ItÕs an uneasy,
maybe a confused relation. We
really are a friendly easy-to-get-on-with lot, but we so strongly dissent from
the mainstream ways, that I have to say there is a strand of resentment there.
LetÕs face it, we think weÕre on the right track, and the mainstream
isnÕt. And itÕs important you
know. ItÕs actually a matter of saving the planet. So there is a tension in how we connect with visitors from a
very different situation. Amy puts
it in terms of visitors being aliens.Ó
Mike was not sure on how to respond. He didnÕt recall any reference to
this in any of the correspondence heÕd seen before setting out. He just nodded.
There was a lull and Jan said ÒLetÕs
get back to our landscape. Do you
realise that weÕve crossed two farms to get here?Ó
ÒWell it did look like a
farm when we came out of the trees, but surely that place was too small to be a
farm.Ó Mike said.
ÒYes that was the WilsonÕs
farm, made up of three old house blocks, and thatÕs a common farm area around
here.Ó
ÒEven including the
homestead!Ó Pete added.
ÒYou see many people here
grow lots of things around their houses, for their own use, but also to
sell. Often the quantities are
very small. But they are really
mixed farms. They are parts of
this neighbourhoodÕs agricultural system.
The WilsonÕs actually have two cows, but they donÕt feed them just on
their land. They tether them
around the neighbourhood much of the time. Mol and Mim supply several houses here with their milk and
butter and cheese. Dairy products
are one of the Wilson's sources of income but itÕs a very mixed farm and they
also produce vegetables, flowers, poultry, herbs, honey, and fruit.Ò
ÒWe have much bigger farms
in the area, but they grade down to the point where you would say they are just
home gardens which might sell the odd bunch of surplus carrots now and
then. Most families have backyard
gardens where they produce much of
their own food and they sell or swap what they donÕt use.Ó
Pete came in, Ò...or give it
away. YouÕll see surplus stuff down
at the neighbourhood workshop later, just there for anyone to take.Ó
ÒAnd Harry Wilson is a good
wood turner, and Meg knits. They
sell some of that too from time to time at the weekly market. IÕd say they probably derive their cash
income from about twenty products.Ó
ÓHold on,Ó Mike had to
say. ÒBack up! How did you get
this landscape. How did you end up
with mini-farms, right in the middle of what used to be a normal town?Ó
ÒWell the farms and gardens
and these woodlots and ponds have just been put on land that was backyards, or parks, or wasteland, or
land beside the railway line. And
then there is the space that was unused at the back of the hospital, and all
the nature strips even where roads were left, and of course then there were all
the roads we dug up. Did you know
that in a normal city roads and cars and parking lots take up more than
one-third of the space. Convert
some of that to fruit and nut trees and youÕre off to a good start.Ó
A knock at the front door. ÒWhoÕs that?Ó Jan said to herself, as she
left the room. She came back accompanied by a somewhat short and slight older
man in scruffy overalls and a battered straw hat, wearing glasses and carrying
a large basket.
ÒMike meet Barry. HeÕs just
brought us some eggs.Ó
ÒHello,Ó said Barry. ÒHave Jan and Pete run you off your
feet yet?Ó
ÒNot really, only just
arrived.Ó
ÒIÕm sure theyÕll wear you
out fast.Ó
ÒCan we have a dozen
Barry?Ó Jan said. ÒI think that
will do. Oh, I should check; Mike
do you like eggs?Ó
ÒYes.Ó
ÒOur hens more or less keep
us in eggs for most of the year, but when we have someone else in the house, we
need to get more in. These are
from the WilsonÕs. I couldÕve got
some from the co-op, but May said Barry could drop some off. Do you have some
for others Barry?Ó
ÒYes, MayÕs got me running
errands all over the place, IÕve still got three lots to drop off.Ó
He was such a quiet and timid looking man, Mike thought, and he couldnÕt
classify him at all confidently.
He was well spoken and seemed slow, but maybe it was just his retiring
nature. He smiled a lot. MikeÕs
best bet was that he was a timid old grandpa and made himself useful doing odd
jobs when asked, such as delivering eggs.
After a few more words with Jan, he said ÒCheerioÓ to Mike, predicting
that their paths would cross again before long.
Jan called after him, ÒTell May to debit me a dozen in case I forget.Ó
Pete explained, ÒThat means
record us as owing for the eggs.
May tells the accounts office who owes what to whom, and later we all
send in our debts and credits. Someone types them in and at the end of the
month a computer sends us a statement.
You more or less try to keep your trading account around zero over time.
If you find youÕre in debt at the end of the month, you make a note to supply a
little more to people than you get for a while. ItÕs a cashless exchange system.Ó
ÒWhat do you trade?Ó
ÒMore or less anything you want to sell and anyone wants to buy. Mostly produce from home gardens and
crafts, but also things like piano lessons.Ó
ÒWhat if someone runs up a big debt and canÕt sell enough?Ó said Mike.
ÒYou could just write a money cheque, or better still opt to work it off
on some community project. You can
pay some of your rates or electricity bills by work time inputs, for instance,
on the teams that maintain the windmills or the power linesÓ.
ÒCan I get back to the mini farms?Ó said Mike. ÒI write on economics you know and farms that small canÕt
possibly be viable. They must be
too small to use tractors even.Ó
ÒYes, many of them are. But our farms donÕt use much
machinery. Certainly nothing
large. Some rotary hoes are used,
and the local farm cooperative has two very small tractors the commercial
farmers hire when they need one.
You see much of our produce comes from home gardeners and from permanent
trees and shrubs. Very little
ploughing and digging gets done.
Most of the food producing around here is done by hand, because most of
our farmers are more like home gardeners.
Did you know that the home gardener is by far the most efficient food
producer of all?Ó
ÒNo. ThatÕs not possible!Ó Mike replied. ÒThese days only the
biggest farms can survive. TheyÕre
the most productive, and thatÕs why they drive out all the little ones.Ó
Gran had been sitting quietly in
a chair in the corner and had taken up some knitting. At this point she suddenly said, ÒNot at
all. Yes they get large yields,
but only by using huge amounts of fuel energy, and water and pesticides and
fertilizers. Home gardeners donÕt
have to use any of those inputs.
And home gardeners improve the soil, whereas agribusiness damages it. Agribusiness cannot return soil
nutrients to the soil. All our
scraps and animal waste go back
into our soil. ThatÕs not
possible when food is transported long distances. Do you know how far the average bit of food in the US is
traveling now? Ò
ÒNo.Ó
ÒOne to two thousand
kilometres! Ò
ÒWell that must be the most economic thing to do. If it was cheaper to produce locally
thatÕs what theyÕd do.Ó
It was JanÕs turn. ÒNo.
Whether you measure crop output
in dollar or energy terms the home gardener produces food at far lower cost.Ó
ÒNonsense!Ó said Mike. ÒFarming is done by agribusiness now,
because big and mechanised and computerised is most efficient. They wouldnÕt have got to the top
otherwise.Ó
ÒBut thatÕs because you only
judge in terms of corporate profitability. It can take agribusiness ten times as much energy as there
is in the crop to grow it, but we grow perfect food without any energy cost.Ó
GranÕs turn. ÒWell we do use
energy, but itÕs only in the form of porridge.Ó
ÒWhat?Ó said Mike.
ÒShe means our gardeners are
fuelled by breakfast. Our farms
mostly use only human energy, hand tools.
They donÕt require imports of petroleum from the other side of the
world, which could be cut at any moment by wars or price hikes. Ò
ÒBut you canÕt beat
supermarket prices. The
corporations are big and they dominate the market because they are cheapest.Ó
ÒNo.Ó said Gran. ÒOur
bottled tomatoes are cheaper. We
have costed it out.Ó
ÒIncluding labour?Ó
ÒYes, but that should be
accounted as a benefit not a cost, because we love gardening.Ó
ÒAnd that is not taking into
account many factors like the energy and pesticides and fertilizers we donÕt
have to use to produce our tomatoes.Ó
ÒNor the energy cost of trucking them to and from the
supermarket,Ó Pete said. ÒNor the
energy to light and clean the supermarket.Ó
ÒAnd then there are the
intangible things like the sensation of cooking with and eating vegies you
produced yourself. ThatÕs nice,
apart from the freshness and the fact that you know they have no pesticides in
them.Ó
ÒAnd above all a home grown tomato has a far better taste than the
plastic ones you have to buy from the supermarkets.Ó
Mike was getting a little
annoyed. ÒNo. No. If you could beat agribusiness the
supermarkets would buy from you.Ó
ÒOh, no, there are many
reasons why they prefer to buy from agribusiness. They can buy 100 tonnes in one order, from a crop
genetically designed to all ripen at the same time. TheyÕre not going to buy from 10,000 little gardeners like
us are they?Ó
ÒAnd think about that
uniformity in the crop; thatÕs bad.
In biology preserving diversity is important. We are losing thousands of varieties because agribusiness
wants to grow only the very few that maximise their profits. They get all the tomatoes to ripen on
the same day, but the last thing a home gardener wants is for all the tomatoes
to ripen at once. We want to be
able to duck out for one or two a day for a month from the same vines.Ó
ÒAnd the food from the home
gardener, or the small local market gardener, is of much higher quality than
what you get from the supermarket.
ThatÕs been stored and itÕs full of preservatives and pesticides.Ó
ÒAnd of course agribusiness
grows only those varieties that look good and are big, and last a long time on
the shelf, and are tough enough to be packaged and transported. They donÕt develop the varieties that are
most nutritious and tasty, or least dependent on pesticides and fertilizer and
water.Ó
ÒAnd our food is very
fresh. We can eat carrots here a
few minutes after they were growing in the ground.Ó
ÒAnd that in turn means we
have few fridges here, and little packaging. We donÕt have to store food for long before its used. The vegetables in your supermarket have
probably been dead for weeks, oozing out vitamins all the time. For example, if we have roast chicken
for tea, that rooster could have still been strutting around at afternoon tea
time.Ó
ÒAnd
there is one very important thing we havenÕt mentioned yet,Ó said Gran. ÒSmall farms give a very satisfying
livelihood to many little people who just love small farming. The economy you have come from couldnÕt
care less about them. It just strips
them off their land and into unemployment, because it allows some giant
corporation to take their business and livelihood.Ó
Mike felt somewhat
overwhelmed, having been unable to get a word in, and was not convinced, but
decided to let the issue go for a while at least. ÒI like the greenhouses, up against the house walls here and
there. TheyÕd be nice to wander
into on a cold day.Ó
Pete said, ÒYes they are.
But greenhouses are also used to
warm our housesÉÓ
ÒHow do they do that?Ó
ÒOh just by ducting the warm
air from the greenhouse into the main house, sometimes with a small fan, but
mostly by the normal tendency for the warm air to rise.Ó
ÒSorry, I cut you off. What
were you going to say, about other things they do?Ó
ÒOur greenhouses are also
fish farms, house air coolers in summer, and hen houses.Ó
ÒYouÕd better explain. How can a greenhouse be a fish farm and
a hen house?Ó
Jan jumped to her feet.
ÒCome on. Best way is to have a
look. ThatÕs AmandaÕs place next door. She wonÕt mind us popping in to her
greenhouse. Be back soon
Gran. Ò
Within two minutes Jan was
opening the glass door into a cavernous jungle of green, with hardly enough
space for a person to walk down the narrow little path between shelves packed
with pots, plants and containers..
ÒSee,Ó said Jan pointing,
ÒÉdown at the end, those are small water tanks . They produce pond plants, and fish. See in the bigger one at the back,
theyÕre Tilapia. Amanda cemented a
glass sheet in the front so the kids could see them swimming. You can raise a lot of fish in small
tanks. And see here, this is where
the hens roost in the corner of the greenhouse, behind a wire screen that keeps
them away from the plants. The
greenhouse helps to warm them in winter and they help to warm it., They get in at night through the
opening there, from their run outside.
Their breathing throughout the night and their droppings add carbon to
the atmosphere. That increases
plant growth.Ó
Pete elaborated. ÒThatÕs an example of how we get things
to overlap. I mean we try to put
things together so that the needs of one are met by something the other does
naturally. In this case the hens
get warm automatically in the greenhouse while they provide carbon dioxide to
it. Meanwhile they also provide eggs,
meat, feathers, and manure for the gardens.Ó
ÒYes, thatÕs really
important,Ó Jan said. ÒThatÕs an
essential Permaculture principle.
You always try to design your systems so that any one thing is
performing many functions, and
benefiting in several ways from other things in the system. For example ducks provide eggs, but
they also provide feathers for insulating clothing and making pillows, and they
produce ducklings...Ó
ÒAnd theyÕre a great source
of entertainment! Ò Pete said.
ÒTheyÕre comical and self-important, and bunglers, and clumsy. Being able to watch them now and
then is part of my leisure and
entertainment world. And the
ducks benefit from other aspects of the system. For example the gardens sometimes have pests like slugs, and
the ducks like eating snails and slugs.
Many things in a well designed system perform functions automatically
for each other, whereas in conventional agriculture you would buy
energy-intensive products to kill the snails, and energy-intensive food for the
ducks.Ó
ÒAnd anyway the snails would
be on one farm that was growing nothing but lettuces while the ducks were on
another farm miles away...Ó
Ò...eating food trucked in,
rather than finding their own snails.
In fact they wouldnÕt even touch the ground let alone be scrabbling
through lettuces. Did you know
that in factory farms hens are kept all their lives in a cage that legally has
to be no bigger than and A4 sheet of paper?Ó
Pete didnÕt wait for an
answer. ÒAnd of course the water
in the fish tanks in the greenhouse is a great heat store. The sunlight warms up the water in the
day time and it keeps the greenhouse warm overnight. No fuel is burnt to keep it warm.Ó
ÒWe have three little fish
farms in this neighbourhood. Many
people have a small number of fish in some tanks around the house, but we have
three families whose main source of income is fish grown in their tanks, or in
community ponds that theyÕve leased.
Come and look.Ó
Pete led the way out of the
greenhouse, and pointed into the middle distance. ÒSee that water down there, about 200 metres away. ThatÕs the Smith Street lake, although
itÕs really only a shallow pond excavated where two roads used to cross. We dug it. Took the earth to make two houses and some animal
sheds. One fish farmer has the
lease on that while itÕs used by all of us for recreation. I mean the kids can paddle their
canoes, at the same time it is growing bigger fish that Bob Simmons will net
some day and sell.Ó
ÒWhat do the fish eat?Ó
ÒAt the domestic level their
foodÕs mostly household scraps, but farm wastes can go in. With small ponds you have to change the
water from time to time, so thatÕs a great source of nutrients for the garden. Some things are specially grown
to feed them, like worms, but mostly they just feed on the critters growing in
the pond. See all the thick reeds
and rushes around the edge. The
pontÕs also part of the drainage system for the neighbourhood so nutrients are
coming in all the time. In other
words the lake catches nutrients that would be wasted in run off and enables
them to be recycled through food.Ó
ÒAgain you can see the
interlocking functions. Our worm
farms obviously contribute to soil enrichment and recycling of food wastes, but
some worms also go into fish feed.
All food scraps end up back in the soils or ponds, but on the way it
makes sense if they can be food for animals. The nutrients are actually improved for the soil if they go
through an animal, rather than straight into the compost heap.Ó
Pete suddenly said, ÒHey I
forgot to explain how the greenhouse cools the main house in summer. See back there, on the top, that vent
allows warm air flow out through the roof and another there low down opening
into the greenhouse from the house.
As the hot air flows out of the greenhouse it draws air from the house
via the low vent, and that draws cool air into the house from a fernery at the
back of the house.Ó
ÒLetÕs go for a
ramble,Ó said Jan.
ÒI should be writing a few
things down,Ó said Mike. Ò Can you
wait till I go in and get my pad?Ó
When he returned Jan led
off. After walking for a few
seconds they came onto a broad cement footpath.
ÒThis is one of the original
footpaths. It was beside the road,
which you can see used to be here.
The footpath is now a cycle way.
They run all over the neighbourhood. This oneÕs been widened a bit, so in an emergency a fire
truck or an ambulance could get along here, to access these houses that are not
on a road now.Ó
ÒIn general we left the path
on the southern side, when we dug up the roads. In the winter the path is in the sun, because the trees are
deciduous.Ó
Mike said, ÒYes, I was just
thinking what a lot of leaves must come down in Autumn.Ó